Comment on "On the emergence of preferred structures in quantum theory" by Soulas, Franzmann, and Di Biagio

This paper argues that Soulas et al.'s proposed construction of a unique tensor product structure fails as a counterexample to Stoica's impossibility proof because it cannot simultaneously maintain invariance and compatibility with physical observations, thereby confirming the trilemma that preferred structures cannot emerge solely from the Hamiltonian and state vector.

Ovidiu Cristinel StoicaTue, 10 Ma⚛️ quant-ph

Observational Indistinguishability and the Beginning of the Universe

This paper argues that we cannot empirically determine whether the universe had a beginning, demonstrating that common defenses of a cosmic origin rely on confirmation theory errors and that, due to extensions of the Malament-Manchak theorems, observers in almost all classical spacetimes cannot distinguish between models with a past singularity and those that are beginningless or lack the requisite time ordering.

Daniel Linford2026-03-05🔬 physics