← Latest papers
⚛️ phenomenology

Next-to-leading-order QCD corrections to radiative decays of fully heavy tetraquarks into quarkonia

This paper calculates the next-to-leading-order QCD corrections to the radiative decays of fully heavy tetraquarks into quarkonia and photons within nonrelativistic QCD factorization, finding that these corrections significantly enhance the decay widths and reduce renormalization scale dependence, thereby predicting observable yields for such processes at the LHC.

Original author: Yu-Dong Zhang, Zai-Fu Jiang

Published 2026-11-10
📖 1 min read🧠 Deep dive

Original author: Yu-Dong Zhang, Zai-Fu Jiang

Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). ✨ This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer

Technical Summary: Next-to-leading-order QCD corrections to radiative decays of fully heavy tetraquarks into quarkonia

Problem and Motivation
Following the observation of the X(6900)X(6900) structure and other enhancements in the di-charmonium spectrum by LHCb, CMS, and ATLAS, there is a pressing need to clarify the internal structure of fully heavy tetraquarks (T4Q=QQQˉQˉT_{4Q} = QQ\bar{Q}\bar{Q}, where Q=c,bQ=c, b). While di-quarkonium decays have been extensively studied, radiative decays into an SS-wave heavy quarkonium and a photon (T4Q→VQ/ηQ+γT_{4Q} \to V_Q/\eta_Q + \gamma) offer complementary channels. These channels are kinematically accessible even for tetraquark masses below the di-quarkonium threshold and allow for reconstruction via dilepton decays of the final-state quarkonium.

Previous leading-order (LO) calculations of these radiative decays by Yang et al. established the basic framework but left open questions regarding the magnitude of QCD corrections and the stability of predictions against renormalization scale variations. Given that the leading QCD contribution to the widths is of order ααs4\alpha \alpha_s^4, the LO predictions are highly sensitive to the renormalization scale. Furthermore, consistency checks of the Nonrelativistic QCD (NRQCD) factorization framework for tetraquark-to-quarkonium transitions require verifying that ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) divergences cancel at the next-to-leading-order (NLO).

Methodology
The authors calculate the NLO QCD corrections to the radiative decays of compact T4QT_{4Q} states with quantum numbers JPC=0++,1+−,2++J^{PC} = 0^{++}, 1^{+-}, 2^{++} into vector (VQV_Q) or pseudoscalar (ηQ\eta_Q) quarkonia and a photon. The calculation is performed within the NRQCD factorization framework, which separates short-distance coefficients (SDCs) from long-distance matrix elements (LDMEs).

  1. Factorization Setup: The decay widths are expressed as products of perturbatively calculable SDCs and non-perturbative LDMEs. For the 0++0^{++} state, both color configurations (3ˉ⊗3\bar{3} \otimes 3 and 6⊗6ˉ6 \otimes \bar{6}) and their interference are included. For 1+−1^{+-} and 2++2^{++}, only the 3ˉ⊗3\bar{3} \otimes 3 configuration contributes at LO in the velocity expansion.
  2. Perturbative Calculation: The authors perform a matching calculation between full QCD and NRQCD. They replace the bound tetraquark and quarkonium with free, on-shell QQQˉQˉQQ\bar{Q}\bar{Q} and QQˉQ\bar{Q} states, respectively.
    • Tree-level and one-loop diagrams for the process QQQˉQˉ→QQˉ+γQQ\bar{Q}\bar{Q} \to Q\bar{Q} + \gamma are generated using FeynArts, resulting in 288 tree and 11,340 one-loop diagrams.
    • Spin and color projectors are applied to isolate specific quantum number configurations.
    • Dimensional regularization (D=4−2ϵD = 4 - 2\epsilon) is used to regulate UV and IR divergences.
    • Renormalization is performed in the on-shell scheme for heavy quark mass and field, and the MS‾\overline{\text{MS}} scheme for the strong coupling αs\alpha_s.
    • The calculation utilizes tools such as FeynCalc, FormLink, FORM, Apart, FIRE, and Package-X to handle algebraic manipulation, integration-by-parts reduction, and master integral evaluation.
  3. Analytic Derivation: Analytic expressions for the SDCs are derived through NLO, retaining terms through O(ααs5)O(\alpha \alpha_s^5) in the squared amplitude, explicitly retaining the dependence on the renormalization scale μR\mu_R.

Key Contributions

  • First NLO Calculation: This work provides the first NLO QCD corrections for the radiative decays of fully heavy tetraquarks into quarkonia.
  • Interference Terms: The authors derive analytic expressions for the interference contribution between the two color configurations (3ˉ⊗3\bar{3} \otimes 3 and 6⊗6ˉ6 \otimes \bar{6}) for the 0++0^{++} state, a feature absent in previous LO studies.
  • Consistency Check: The calculation demonstrates that all UV divergences are exactly canceled by renormalization and that the resulting SDCs are free of both UV and IR poles after matching, validating the NRQCD factorization for these transitions at NLO.
  • Comprehensive Phenomenology: The study covers both charmed (T4cT_{4c}) and bottom (T4bT_{4b}) tetraquarks, providing predictions for various spin-parity states (0++,1+−,2++0^{++}, 1^{+-}, 2^{++}).

Results
The authors present analytic formulas for the SDCs and evaluate the decay widths using representative sets of LDMEs derived from potential models.

  • Enhancement Factors: The NLO QCD corrections significantly enhance the decay widths.
    • For T4c→J/ψ+γT_{4c} \to J/\psi + \gamma (2++2^{++}) and T4c→ηc+γT_{4c} \to \eta_c + \gamma (1+−1^{+-}), the widths increase by factors of approximately 2.94 and 2.22, respectively.
    • For T4bT_{4b}, the corresponding enhancement factors are 2.33 and 1.83.
    • For the 0++0^{++} channel, the enhancement is more complex due to interference. For T4cT_{4c}, the total width increases by factors of 2.86 (Set 1) and 2.27 (Set 2). For T4bT_{4b}, the enhancement ranges from 1.79 to 5.45 depending on the interference pattern (constructive or destructive) and the LDME set.
  • Scale Dependence: The dependence on the renormalization scale μR\mu_R is generally reduced at NLO compared to LO, although a sizable residual dependence remains. For instance, in the T4c→J/ψ+γT_{4c} \to J/\psi + \gamma (2++2^{++}) channel, the variation of the width when μR\mu_R is changed from mQm_Q to 4mQ4m_Q drops from ∼168%\sim 168\% at LO to ∼116%\sim 116\% at NLO.
  • Event Yields: Using LO production cross-sections and NLO branching fractions, the authors estimate the number of observable events at the LHC (s=13\sqrt{s} = 13 TeV, L=100 fb−1\mathcal{L} = 100 \text{ fb}^{-1}):
    • T4c→J/ψ+γT_{4c} \to J/\psi + \gamma: Yields of order 10610^6 to 10710^7.
    • T4c→ηc+γT_{4c} \to \eta_c + \gamma: Yields of order 10410^4.
    • The J/ψ+γJ/\psi + \gamma channels are identified as promising for experimental investigation via the ℓ+ℓ−γ\ell^+\ell^-\gamma invariant-mass spectrum.

Significance
The paper claims that these results provide a necessary consistency check for the NRQCD factorization framework applied to tetraquark-to-quarkonium transitions. By demonstrating the cancellation of divergences and quantifying the large NLO corrections, the work establishes a more reliable theoretical baseline for interpreting experimental data from LHCb, CMS, and ATLAS. The authors note that while the NLO corrections reduce scale uncertainty, the residual dependence suggests that higher-order corrections may still be relevant. The estimated yields indicate that these radiative decay channels are experimentally accessible and offer a valuable complement to searches in di-charmonium final states for probing the nature of fully heavy tetraquarks.

Drowning in papers in your field?

Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.

Try Digest →