Axion-Photon Conversion in Variable-Domain Magnetic Fields and the Highest-Energy Photons from GRB 221009A
This paper proposes that axion-photon conversion within a host galaxy's magnetic field characterized by variable domain lengths can simultaneously explain the ultra-high-energy photons from GRB 221009A detected by LHAASO and Carpet-3, yielding axion parameters that remain consistent with current experimental bounds.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
Deep in the cosmos, light travels as a stream of particles called photons, carrying energy across billions of miles. However, when these photons are extremely energetic, they face a significant obstacle on their journey to Earth. As they cross the vast spaces between galaxies, they collide with a faint, ancient glow of low-energy light that fills the universe. These collisions are destructive; they cause the high-energy photons to vanish, transforming into pairs of particles that no longer travel as light. For decades, astronomers believed this process meant that the most powerful bursts of light from distant explosions should be completely blocked before they could reach our telescopes. Yet, in late 2022, a spectacular gamma-ray burst named GRB 221009A defied this expectation. Observatories on Earth detected not only a flood of high-energy light but also a single, record-breaking photon with an energy of roughly 300 trillion electron volts. This particle should have been absorbed long ago, leaving scientists with a puzzle: how did this photon survive the journey?
The answer proposed by a team of researchers involves a hypothetical particle known as an axion. Axions are a type of particle predicted by theories that extend our current understanding of physics. They are incredibly light and interact so weakly with normal matter that they can pass through almost anything without stopping. A key feature of these particles is their ability to change form. In the presence of a magnetic field, a photon can transform into an axion, and an axion can transform back into a photon. This process acts like a secret escape route. If a high-energy photon converts into an axion while near its source, it can travel through the dangerous, light-filled void of intergalactic space unharmed. Once it reaches the magnetic fields of our own galaxy, it can convert back into a photon, arriving at Earth just in time to be detected.
In their study, the researchers investigated whether this conversion process could explain the mysterious 300 TeV photon from GRB 221009A, as well as the broader spectrum of high-energy light observed by the LHAASO observatory. They focused on the magnetic fields surrounding the host galaxy of the burst. Previous attempts to explain the data using axions assumed that these magnetic fields were uniform, like a series of identical rooms with the same size and orientation. However, the new study modeled the magnetic field as a collection of domains with varying lengths and random directions, reflecting the turbulent and complex nature of real astrophysical environments. By simulating the journey of the photon-axion system through the host galaxy, the space between galaxies, and finally through the Milky Way, the team calculated the probability of the photon surviving the trip.
The results showed that the variability of the magnetic domains was crucial. When the researchers assumed the magnetic domains were all the same size, the model failed to account for the 300 TeV photon without contradicting strict laboratory limits on how strongly axions can interact with light. However, when they allowed the domain lengths to vary, the survival probability for the highest-energy photons increased significantly. This adjustment allowed the model to fit both the LHAASO data and the Carpet-3 detection of the 300 TeV photon using only the axion conversion mechanism. The best fit for the data suggested an axion mass of 3.85 × 10⁻⁷ eV and a specific coupling strength to photons of 3.07 × 10⁻¹¹ GeV⁻¹. Importantly, these values fall within the range allowed by the CAST experiment, a major laboratory test that has ruled out many other theoretical possibilities.
This finding offers a compelling solution to the mystery of the ultra-high-energy photon without needing to invoke new, unproven laws of physics or violations of fundamental symmetries. The study demonstrates that the structure of magnetic fields in distant galaxies plays a vital role in how light travels across the universe. By accounting for the natural variation in these fields, the researchers showed that axions could provide a natural pathway for the most energetic light to reach us, turning a cosmic impossibility into a plausible reality. The work highlights that the details of how magnetic fields are arranged in space can fundamentally change our understanding of what we see in the night sky.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.