, Radiative Dirac Neutrinos, and Flavor Physics from Leptoquarks
This paper proposes a model with two mixed scalar leptoquarks and three right-handed neutrinos that successfully generates radiative Dirac neutrino masses and accommodates the Belle II measurement of while satisfying constraints from charged-lepton flavor violation and cosmological limits, notably demonstrating that cosmological bounds on the leptoquark mass scale can be stronger than those from direct collider searches.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
The universe is filled with particles that make up everything we see, from the stars above to the atoms in our bodies. Among these, neutrinos are the most elusive. They are ghostly, nearly massless particles that pass through planets and people without ever stopping or interacting. For decades, physicists have been puzzled by two deep mysteries regarding these particles. First, why are they so incredibly light compared to every other known particle? Second, are they their own antiparticles, or are they distinct from them? While the standard model of physics describes the known universe well, it cannot explain these quirks. To solve them, scientists often look for new, invisible forces or particles that might be hiding just beyond our current view. One promising idea involves a hypothetical particle called a leptoquark. As the name suggests, this particle acts as a bridge, capable of turning a quark (which makes up protons and neutrons) into a lepton (a family that includes electrons and neutrinos). If these particles exist, they could explain why neutrinos have mass and why they behave the way they do.
A team of researchers recently explored a specific version of this idea, proposing a model where two different types of these leptoquarks interact with three new, invisible neutrinos. Their goal was to see if this setup could solve the mystery of neutrino mass while also explaining a strange observation made by the Belle II experiment in Japan. That experiment measured how often a specific heavy particle, called a B-meson, decays into a lighter particle and a pair of neutrinos. The rate they observed was significantly higher than what the standard model predicts, suggesting that something new is happening. The researchers built a mathematical framework to test if their leptoquark model could produce this excess rate without breaking other known laws of physics. They found that it is possible, but only under very specific conditions. The model works by having the leptoquarks mix in a way that generates tiny neutrino masses through a loop-like process, rather than a direct one. This same mixing also allows the B-meson to decay more frequently, matching the Belle II data.
However, the universe is a strict judge, and any new theory must pass several tests. The researchers checked their model against three major constraints. First, they looked at the stability of matter. If the leptoquarks interact too strongly, they could cause a muon (a heavy cousin of the electron) to spontaneously turn into an electron and a photon, a process that has never been seen. Their calculations showed that the model can avoid this disaster, but only if the leptoquarks are heavy enough. Second, they considered the early history of the universe. The new neutrinos in their model could have been produced in the hot moments after the Big Bang. If too many were created, they would have changed the expansion rate of the universe in a way that contradicts what we see in the cosmic microwave background. The team found that the model can satisfy this cosmological limit, but again, it requires the leptoquarks to be quite massive. Finally, they checked if the model remained mathematically consistent, meaning the numbers used to describe the interactions did not grow so large that the theory broke down.
The results of this study reveal a delicate balance. The model can successfully explain the unusual B-meson decay and the tiny mass of neutrinos, but it pushes the leptoquarks to be much heavier than some scientists hoped. The researchers found that if both types of leptoquarks are heavier than about 12 to 14 trillion electron volts, the new effects become too weak to explain the Belle II measurement, and the decay rate would fall back to the standard model prediction. Interestingly, the study showed that the limits imposed by the early universe's expansion are sometimes even stricter than the limits from particle colliders. In some scenarios, the cosmological rules require the leptoquarks to be so heavy that they would be impossible to create with current technology, even though the theory itself remains valid. This suggests that looking at the history of the cosmos can sometimes tell us more about the existence of new particles than smashing atoms together in a machine.
The team also provided four specific examples, or benchmarks, of how this model could work. In one scenario, the new particles interact mostly through a right-handed force, keeping the dangerous flavor-changing processes very low. In another, the interactions are mixed, allowing the model to fit the data while staying just within the safety limits of the muon decay experiments. These examples show that there is no single way for the model to work; it can adapt to different combinations of particle masses and interaction strengths. The study concludes that while this leptoquark framework is a viable candidate for explaining the mysteries of neutrinos and B-mesons, it comes with a price. The particles must be heavy, and their interactions must be tuned precisely. If future experiments at the Belle II facility or at the Large Hadron Collider find that the B-meson decay rate returns to the standard model prediction, or if they discover the muon decay process, this specific version of the leptoquark theory would be ruled out. Until then, the ghostly neutrinos and the heavy leptoquarks remain a compelling, if elusive, possibility for understanding the deeper structure of our universe.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.