Indefinite causal order with definite Bohmian trajectories for the quantum switch
This paper demonstrates that within the deterministic de Broglie–Bohm framework, the quantum switch and entangled systems exhibiting indefinite causal order can be described using well-defined particle trajectories that preserve a strict causal order, even in scenarios where standard quantum mechanics suggests causal indefiniteness.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
For nearly a century, physicists have debated whether the universe follows a strict script of cause and effect, or if the rules of the quantum world allow for something far stranger. In the classical view, events happen in a clear line: a cause precedes its effect, and time flows in one direction. But in the quantum realm, where particles can exist in multiple states at once, this linear logic seemed to break down. Scientists began to imagine scenarios where the order of events itself could be blurred, a concept known as indefinite causal order. In such a scenario, it would be impossible to say whether event A happened before event B, or vice versa; both orders would exist simultaneously in a superposition. This idea has moved from theoretical speculation to experimental reality, most notably through a device called the quantum switch. This machine takes a particle and sends it through two different operations, but instead of forcing the particle to experience them in a fixed sequence, it places the sequence itself into a quantum superposition. To many researchers, this suggests that the fundamental structure of time and causality might be far more fluid than we ever imagined.
A new study by physicist Aurélien Drezet challenges this prevailing view by looking at the quantum switch through a different lens. Rather than accepting the standard interpretation that causal order can truly be indefinite, Drezet applies a specific framework known as de Broglie-Bohm theory, or pilot-wave theory. This approach, which was largely set aside in the mid-20th century in favor of the more popular Copenhagen interpretation, insists that particles always have definite positions and follow precise, deterministic paths through space and time, guided by a wave function. In this view, there is no randomness in the motion of individual particles, only in our knowledge of where they started. By running detailed simulations of the quantum switch using this framework, Drezet demonstrates that the appearance of indefinite causal order is an illusion created by the complexity of the guiding wave. When you look closely at the actual path a particle takes, it always follows one specific, well-defined history.
The researchers modeled the quantum switch as an interferometer, a device that splits a particle's path into two branches and then recombines them. In the standard operational view, if the particle is in a superposition of taking the path where operation A happens before B, and the path where B happens before A, the causal order is considered indefinite. However, in the simulations performed by Drezet, the particle is treated as a real object with a specific location at every moment. The results show that the particle never actually experiences both orders at once. Instead, it travels along a single, continuous trajectory. Depending on its initial position, the particle will either follow the path where A precedes B, or the path where B precedes A. The "superposition" exists only in the wave that guides the particle, not in the particle's actual journey through time. The study effectively argues that while the wave function can be in a superposition of different causal histories, the particle itself always has a single, definite story to tell.
This finding has significant implications for how we interpret recent experiments that claim to have verified indefinite causal order. Some researchers have used "device-independent" methods, which rely on mathematical inequalities to prove that a system cannot be explained by any fixed causal order, to certify that the quantum switch is working as intended. These tests suggest that no hidden variables or pre-determined paths could explain the results. Drezet's work, however, shows that these conclusions depend on specific assumptions about how the universe works, particularly the assumption that local causality holds true. Because the pilot-wave theory is explicitly non-local—meaning a change in one part of the system can instantly affect the path of a particle far away—it can reproduce the exact same experimental results as the standard quantum theory while maintaining a strict, definite causal order. The simulations show that the particle's path is influenced by distant settings in a way that standard physics calls "spooky," but which allows the particle to retain a single, coherent history.
The study does not claim to disprove the existence of the quantum switch or the strange correlations it produces. Instead, it offers an alternative explanation for what is happening inside the machine. The researchers argue that the concept of indefinite causal order is a useful tool for engineering and information processing, much like the concept of wave-particle duality was useful for understanding light. However, just as wave-particle duality does not mean a particle is literally a wave and a particle at the same time in a physical sense, indefinite causal order does not mean the particle is traveling through time in two directions at once. In the de Broglie-Bohm picture, the particle is always a particle, moving along a single track. The confusion arises because we are trying to describe the behavior of the guiding wave using the language of particle trajectories, or vice versa. The paper suggests that if we accept that particles have real, definite paths, the paradox of indefinite causal order dissolves, leaving us with a universe that is still deterministic and causal, even if it is non-local.
Ultimately, this research serves as a reminder that our understanding of quantum mechanics is still evolving. The quantum switch remains a powerful tool for exploring the limits of information processing, and its ability to outperform traditional circuits is a fact of experimental reality. But the interpretation of what that means for the nature of time and causality is not settled. By showing that a deterministic model with definite trajectories can reproduce all the predictions of the quantum switch, the study suggests that the "indefinite" nature of causal order might be a feature of how we choose to describe the system, rather than a fundamental property of the universe itself. The particle, in this view, never loses its way; it simply follows a path that is guided by a wave that knows the whole story at once.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.