On Quantised Magnetic Monopoles in the Nonlocal Electromagnetic Field
This paper demonstrates that within the Moffat-Thompson nonlocal quantum field theory, magnetic monopoles can exist as finite-energy distributions while preserving electromagnetic duality, though Dirac's quantization condition implies their production requires significantly higher energy than electric charges, thereby explaining their extreme rarity and detection difficulty.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
For nearly a century, physicists have grappled with a profound asymmetry in the universe. On one side, we have electric charge, a property carried by electrons and protons that powers our lights and drives our technology. On the other side, we have the magnetic field, the invisible force that guides compass needles and holds our hard drives together. In the standard laws of physics, these two forces are mirror images of each other, yet nature seems to favor one. Electric charges exist in isolation; you can hold a single electron in your hand. Magnetic charges, however, have never been found alone. If you break a magnet in two, you do not get a separate north pole and a separate south pole; you simply get two smaller magnets, each with both poles. Theoretical physics has long suggested that isolated magnetic charges, known as monopoles, should exist to complete the symmetry of the universe. Yet, despite decades of searching in cosmic rays and particle accelerators, no one has ever detected one.
This mystery has led to a persistent question: are magnetic monopoles forbidden by the laws of nature, or are they simply hiding in plain sight, too difficult to create or too heavy to find? A new study by researchers at the Perimeter Institute, the University of Toronto, and Wilfrid Laurier University suggests that the answer lies in the very fabric of space and time at the smallest scales. By applying a theory that treats the electromagnetic field as "nonlocal"—meaning that the influence of a particle is not confined to a single point but is spread out over a tiny region—the researchers have shown that magnetic monopoles could be perfectly allowed by the fundamental equations of physics. However, the theory also reveals that creating such a particle would require an enormous amount of energy, explaining why they have remained elusive despite our best efforts to find them.
The story begins with the work of Paul Dirac in 1931, who showed that if even a single magnetic monopole existed in the universe, it would force all electric charges to come in specific, discrete amounts. This idea, known as charge quantization, is a cornerstone of modern physics. Dirac's math also implied a strange relationship between the strength of electric and magnetic forces. Because the electric force is relatively weak, the magnetic force carried by a monopole would have to be incredibly strong. In the traditional view of physics, where particles are treated as infinitesimal points, this strong magnetic force leads to a mathematical disaster: the energy required to create the magnetic field of a point-like monopole would be infinite. This infinite energy is usually seen as a sign that monopoles cannot exist, or that our current theories break down at that scale.
The researchers in this study asked what would happen if we stopped treating particles as mathematical points and instead assumed that the laws of physics have a built-in "fuzziness" at extremely small distances. This concept comes from a framework called nonlocal quantum field theory, which suggests that the interaction between particles is smeared out over a tiny, finite width rather than happening at a single, sharp location. When the team applied this nonlocal perspective to the equations governing magnetic monopoles, the infinite energy problem vanished. The sharp, singular point of the monopole was replaced by a smooth, finite distribution of charge. The magnetic field still existed, and the total amount of magnetic charge remained exactly what Dirac predicted, but the energy stored in that field became finite and calculable.
The results were surprising. While the theory successfully removed the infinite energy problem, it did not make the monopole easy to find. In fact, the calculations showed that the energy required to create the smallest possible magnetic monopole is thousands of times greater than the energy required to create an electrically charged particle of similar size. This massive energy gap arises directly from the relationship between electric and magnetic strength established by Dirac. Because the electric force is so weak, the magnetic force must be so strong that the energy needed to assemble a magnetic monopole becomes astronomical. The researchers calculated that the energy threshold for creating a pair of these particles would be roughly nineteen times a specific fundamental energy scale defined by the theory.
This finding offers a new perspective on why we have not seen magnetic monopoles. It suggests that they are not forbidden by the laws of physics; rather, they are simply too expensive to produce. The universe may be full of them in theory, but the energy required to bring them into existence is so high that our current particle accelerators, and perhaps even the most violent cosmic events, cannot reach the necessary threshold. The study also clarifies a subtle point about how energy is measured in such theories. The researchers found that if one calculates the energy using a simplified version of the equations, the result is lower than if one calculates it using the full, fundamental action of the theory. The more rigorous calculation, which accounts for the nonlocal nature of the field, yields the higher energy value, reinforcing the conclusion that these particles are exceptionally heavy.
The implications of this work extend beyond just the search for a missing particle. It demonstrates that the symmetry between electricity and magnetism can be preserved even if the two forces behave very differently in practice. The equations can treat electric and magnetic charges as equals, while the physical reality makes one easy to find and the other nearly impossible to create. This resolves a long-standing tension in physics where the mathematical beauty of symmetry seemed to clash with the observational fact that monopoles are absent. The study does not claim to have found a monopole, nor does it predict exactly when or how one might be discovered. Instead, it provides a consistent theoretical framework where monopoles are allowed, their energy is finite, and their extreme mass explains their absence from our detectors.
Ultimately, the paper suggests that the absence of magnetic monopoles in our experiments is not a sign that they do not exist, but a sign that the universe demands a very high price for their creation. The nonlocal nature of the electromagnetic field acts as a filter, smoothing out the singularities that would otherwise make the theory impossible, while simultaneously setting a massive energy barrier that keeps these particles out of reach. If future experiments ever manage to reach the required energy levels, or if we find evidence of these particles in the early universe, it would confirm that the fundamental laws of physics are indeed nonlocal. Until then, the magnetic monopole remains a ghost in the machine: mathematically sound, theoretically permitted, but energetically out of reach.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.