Dirac leptogenesis with charged leptons
This paper proposes a viable Dirac leptogenesis mechanism that incorporates Standard Model charged leptons through a Froggatt-Nielsen framework with higher-dimensional operators, linking fermion mass hierarchies to the baryon asymmetry of the Universe via a supercooled flavon phase transition that predicts a light flavon particle (1.7–50 GeV) testable by future lepton flavor violation experiments.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
The universe we inhabit is made almost entirely of matter, yet the laws of physics suggest that the Big Bang should have produced equal amounts of matter and antimatter. When these two opposites meet, they annihilate each other, leaving behind only pure energy. If the early universe had been perfectly balanced, everything would have vanished, and we would not be here to ask why we exist. Physicists have long searched for a mechanism that tipped the scales, creating a tiny surplus of matter that survived the cosmic fire to form stars, planets, and people. Two main theories have dominated this search: one suggests a violent shift in the state of the early universe, while the other relies on a subtle violation of a conservation rule in the neutrino sector. However, a third, more subtle possibility has gained attention, one that does not require either of those dramatic events.
This alternative path, known as Dirac leptogenesis, proposes that the imbalance began with a difference in the "handedness" of particles. In the subatomic world, particles can be thought of as having a left-handed or right-handed orientation. The standard model of physics treats these two versions differently, but they usually interact so quickly that any difference between them is erased almost instantly. For this mechanism to work, a specific type of particle must remain isolated, keeping its unique orientation separate from the rest of the universe long enough for the imbalance to be converted into the matter we see today. Until now, this idea relied on the existence of extremely light, invisible neutrinos that barely interact with anything. A new study by researchers at the Max Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics in Heidelberg suggests that this mechanism does not need to be so exclusive. They propose that the heavy, charged particles we know well—electrons, muons, and tau leptons—could have played the starring role instead, provided the universe cooled down in a very specific way.
The researchers, Juan Garcés, Florian Goertz, and Maya Hager, explored a scenario where the masses of these charged particles are not fundamental but arise from a more complex, hidden structure. They utilized a theoretical framework called the Froggatt-Nielsen mechanism, which introduces a new field of particles called flavons. In this model, the particles we see today get their mass only after this new field settles into a stable state. Before that moment, the interactions that would normally mix the left-handed and right-handed versions of the charged leptons are suppressed, acting like a high wall that keeps them apart. The key insight of the paper is that if this transition happens late enough, the charged leptons can act as the reservoir for the asymmetry, holding onto their unique state just as the universe's ability to convert lepton imbalances into matter begins to shut down.
To make this work, the universe had to undergo a period of "supercooling." Imagine a liquid that stays liquid even when it is far below its freezing point, waiting for a specific trigger to turn solid. In this cosmic scenario, the new field remained in a high-energy state long after the universe had cooled past the point where the matter-creating processes were active. This delay meant that the interactions which would normally wash out the asymmetry were turned off before they could do any damage. Once the field finally settled, the particles acquired their familiar masses, but by then, the crucial imbalance had already been locked in and converted into the baryon asymmetry that defines our universe. The authors show that this process is mathematically consistent and can reproduce the observed mass differences between the electron, muon, and tau without breaking any known laws of physics.
However, this elegant solution comes with strict constraints. The new field, the flavon, cannot be just any mass; it must fall within a very narrow window to avoid conflicting with experimental data. The researchers calculated that the flavon must have a mass between 1.7 and 50 GeV. If it were lighter, it would have caused rare decays of heavy particles that experiments have not observed. If it were heavier, the energy released when the field finally settled would have reheated the universe too much, reactivating the processes that would have erased the very asymmetry the theory tries to explain. This creates a precise prediction: the flavon exists, but it is light enough to be potentially discovered by future experiments designed to look for violations of lepton flavor, such as the decay of a muon into an electron and a photon.
The study also maps out exactly how heavy the new physics scale must be to allow this scenario to work. For the heavy tau lepton to serve as the asymmetry reservoir, the underlying energy scale must be above a specific threshold. For the muon, it must be above a lower threshold, and for the electron, it can be as low as another threshold. These numbers are not arbitrary; they are the result of balancing the rate at which the universe expands against the rate at which the particles interact. The researchers found that if the new physics scale were any lower, the interactions would have been too fast, and the asymmetry would have been lost before it could be converted into matter.
This work does not claim to have solved the mystery of the matter-antimatter imbalance, but it significantly broadens the landscape of possible solutions. It demonstrates that the mechanism does not require the existence of ultra-light, invisible neutrinos, but can instead rely on the charged leptons that are already part of our standard model. By linking the origin of the universe's matter to the mechanism that gives particles their mass, the paper connects two of the biggest open questions in physics. The proposed framework is testable; as experiments like Mu3e and Mu2e improve their sensitivity to rare particle decays, they will be able to probe the specific mass range predicted by this theory. If the flavon exists within the predicted 1.7 to 50 GeV range, it could be discovered in the coming decade, offering a direct glimpse into the processes that allowed our universe to exist.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.