Local-channel inequivalence within analytic symmetry-broken phases
This paper demonstrates that within analytic symmetry-broken phases, Gibbs states at different temperatures are inequivalent under two-way quasi-local channels because a temperature-dependent constant term in the mutual information—determined by phase stiffness—cannot be increased by such channels, thereby proving that cooling between distinct temperatures in the ordered phase is impossible without non-local resources.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
In the world of physics, matter often organizes itself into distinct states, like water freezing into ice or a magnet aligning its tiny internal arrows. When a material enters such an ordered state, it usually does so because the temperature has dropped low enough to let the atoms settle into a preferred arrangement. For decades, scientists have relied on a standard map to navigate these changes. This map says that if a material's internal energy changes smoothly as it cools, without any sudden jumps or breaks, then the material is in a single, continuous phase. According to this traditional view, you should be able to transform the material from one temperature to another within that same phase using only local operations—small, nearby adjustments that do not require the entire system to communicate instantly. It is a comforting idea: that smooth thermodynamics implies smooth, local control.
However, a new study challenges this assumption by looking closely at what happens when a material breaks a continuous symmetry, a process where the system chooses a specific direction from a circle of infinite possibilities. The researchers focused on two idealized models of matter: a gas of non-interacting particles that can pile up in the same quantum state, and a magnetic model where spins are constrained to avoid forming tiny whirlpools. In both cases, the material remains ordered and its energy changes smoothly as the temperature varies. Yet, the team discovered that despite this smoothness, the material at a colder temperature is fundamentally different from the same material at a warmer temperature in a way that cannot be bridged by local means. They found that the information shared between two distant regions of the material is strictly higher when the material is cold. This difference is so precise that no amount of local manipulation can turn the warm state into the cold one without a massive, system-wide effort.
The researchers proved this by measuring how much two observers, standing far apart, could learn about the shared direction of the material's order. Imagine two people, each holding a large cube of the material, separated by a vast distance. In the ordered state, the entire material points in a random direction that is the same for both cubes, but this direction is hidden by thermal noise. The observers can measure their local cubes to guess this shared direction. The study shows that the colder the material, the more accurately these distant observers can agree on that direction. Specifically, the amount of information they can extract grows with the size of their cubes, but there is a constant term in that information that depends entirely on the temperature. This constant acts like a fingerprint for the temperature.
The team demonstrated that this fingerprint cannot be altered by any process that acts locally. If a local machine tried to cool the material, it would have to increase this information constant. But local operations can only preserve or decrease the information shared between distant regions; they cannot create new shared information out of nothing. Therefore, it is impossible to cool the material from one temperature to a lower one within the ordered phase using only local steps. To achieve such cooling, the process would need to reach across the entire system, with the time or distance required growing linearly with the size of the material. This holds true even though the material's energy changes perfectly smoothly and no phase transition occurs.
This finding separates the thermodynamic definition of a phase from the operational definition based on what local machines can do. The researchers showed that within a single, smooth thermodynamic phase, there exists a continuous spectrum of distinct states that are operationally different. They confirmed this for the ideal gas and the magnetic model, and they extended the logic to quantum versions of these models and systems with multiple directions of order. While they suspect this rule applies to a wide range of materials with broken symmetry, they have rigorously proven it only for these specific, idealized cases. The work reveals that the ability to change a material's temperature locally is far more restricted than previously thought, governed by a hidden information barrier that persists even when the material's energy landscape appears featureless.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.