← Latest papers
🧬 genetics

Genomic and Epigenomic Relationships Capture Different Patterns of Genotype-by-Environment Interaction in Grapevine Clones

This study demonstrates that while genomic relationships primarily explain the main effects of clonal performance in Riesling grapevines, epigenomic relationships capture distinct and substantial patterns of genotype-by-environment interaction, revealing that these two molecular layers provide complementary information for understanding year-to-year variation in clone performance.

Original authors: Robinson, H., Schmidt, M., Callipo, P., Robles-Zazueta, C. A., Brunner, S., Hintzsche, J., Vafadarshamasbi, U., Frotscher, J., Strack, T., Crisp, P. A., Piepho, H.-P., Voss-Fels, K. P.

Published 2026-11-06
📖 6 min read🧠 Deep dive

Original authors: Robinson, H., Schmidt, M., Callipo, P., Robles-Zazueta, C. A., Brunner, S., Hintzsche, J., Vafadarshamasbi, U., Frotscher, J., Strack, T., Crisp, P. A., Piepho, H.-P., Voss-Fels, K. P.

Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). ⚕️ This is an AI-generated explanation of a preprint that has not been peer-reviewed. It is not medical advice. Do not make health decisions based on this content. Read full disclaimer

In the world of agriculture, plants are not static machines that respond to the sun and rain in a predictable, mechanical way. They are living systems where the genetic code written in their DNA interacts constantly with the environment. This interaction, known as genotype-by-environment interaction, is the reason why a plant that thrives in one season might struggle in the next, even if the soil and care remain the same. For farmers and breeders, this unpredictability is a major hurdle. They need to select the best plants to grow, but if a plant's performance changes drastically from year to year, it becomes difficult to know which ones will be reliable. While scientists have long understood that DNA provides the blueprint for a plant, a newer field of study has revealed that there is another layer of information sitting on top of that blueprint. This layer, called epigenetics, acts like a set of switches that can turn genes on or off without changing the underlying code itself. These switches can be influenced by the environment, potentially explaining why genetically identical plants might behave differently when faced with heat, drought, or a particularly wet spring.

A team of researchers set out to understand how much of this yearly variation in grapevines is driven by the permanent genetic code and how much is driven by these flexible epigenetic switches. They focused on Riesling, a famous grape variety that has been grown for centuries. Because grapes are propagated by cutting a piece of an existing vine and planting it, every new vine is a genetic clone of the parent. In theory, a thousand clones of the same vine should be identical. However, over time, these clones accumulate tiny changes. Some are permanent mutations in the DNA sequence, while others are shifts in the epigenetic switches. The researchers wanted to know: when a clone performs well in a hot year and poorly in a cold one, is that because of its DNA, or is it because its epigenetic switches reacted to the weather? To find the answer, they studied 206 different Riesling clones that had been growing in a vineyard in Germany for many years. They measured how much fruit each clone produced and the quality of the juice it made over nine different growing seasons.

To get a clear picture of what was happening inside the vines, the scientists used a specialized technique called UMR-seq. This method allowed them to read two different types of information from the same small sample of leaf tissue. First, they mapped the genetic differences between the clones, looking for tiny variations in the DNA sequence. Second, they mapped the epigenetic landscape, specifically looking at which parts of the DNA were chemically modified to be active or silent. By comparing these two maps against the harvest data from nine years, they could see how each type of information contributed to the vines' performance.

The results revealed a fascinating split in how these two layers of biology work. When the researchers looked at the average performance of the clones across all years, the genetic differences explained most of the variation. The DNA sequence was the primary driver of why one clone produced more fruit than another on average. However, the story changed completely when they looked at how the clones reacted to specific years. When the team modeled the differences between years, the epigenetic layer became the dominant force. For four out of the five traits they measured, the epigenetic switches explained more of the variation in how clones performed from one season to the next than the genetic code did. In other words, while the DNA determined the baseline potential of the vine, the epigenetic switches were largely responsible for how that potential rose or fell in response to the specific weather of a given year.

The researchers also discovered that these two layers were capturing different patterns of behavior. They found that the genetic and epigenetic influences did not just overlap; they seemed to operate in different parts of the genome. When they looked for the specific regions of the DNA where the biggest effects were happening, the areas that mattered most for the genetic differences were rarely the same areas that mattered most for the epigenetic differences. It was as if the two systems were using different tools to solve the same problem. Furthermore, the way the clones re-ranked from year to year differed between the two layers. For some traits, the epigenetic layer showed that the ranking of the best clones remained surprisingly stable across years, while the genetic layer showed more shuffling. This suggests that the epigenetic switches might provide a more consistent signal for how a clone will handle environmental stress than the genetic code alone.

The study also addressed a common assumption in plant breeding: that if you know the genetic relationship between clones, you can predict their performance. The researchers found that simply knowing how closely related two clones were genetically did not help much in predicting how they would handle a specific year's weather. It was only when they included the epigenetic data that they could capture the complex ways the vines responded to the changing environment. This implies that for crops like grapes, which are grown for decades and must survive unpredictable climate shifts, the epigenetic layer holds a key piece of the puzzle that the genetic code misses. The findings suggest that to truly understand how plants adapt to a changing world, scientists need to look beyond the static blueprint and pay close attention to the dynamic switches that allow those blueprints to be read differently in different conditions.

The researchers were careful to note that their study was limited to a single population of Riesling grapes in one location, so these patterns might look different in other varieties or regions. They also acknowledged that they measured the epigenetic state at only one point in time, so they could not track how the switches flipped back and forth throughout the seasons. However, the data provided a strong foundation for the idea that genetic and epigenetic factors contribute to plant performance in distinct and complementary ways. By showing that the epigenetic layer captures a substantial portion of the year-to-year variation, the study opens the door for new ways of selecting grapevines. Instead of just looking for the vines with the best DNA, breeders might one day be able to select for vines with the most resilient epigenetic switches, ensuring that their crops can withstand the increasing volatility of the climate.

Drowning in papers in your field?

Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.

Try Digest →