The Neoplasia as embryological phenomenon and its implication in the animal evolution and the origin of cancer. II. The neoplastic process as an evolutionary engine
This paper proposes that the neoplastic process is an evolutionarily ancient mechanism rooted in the formation of the first animal embryo, serving as a central engine for animal morphogenesis and evolution through the exaptation of unicellular holozoan components into a neoplastic functional module.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of a preprint that has not been peer-reviewed. It is not medical advice. Do not make health decisions based on this content. Read full disclaimer
The Big Idea: Cancer is the "Old Engine" of Life
Imagine that the history of life on Earth is like a massive, ancient car. For a long time, scientists thought the engine (how animals grow and form bodies) and the brakes (what stops cells from growing out of control) were two completely different inventions.
Cofre's hypothesis flips this script. He suggests that the "engine" of animal life and the "engine" of cancer are actually the same machine.
He argues that the very first animal embryo didn't start with a complex blueprint. Instead, it started when single-celled ancestors (like tiny, floating blobs) decided to stick together. To do this, they had to use a "superpower" they already had: the ability to grow rapidly and move around. In modern terms, we call uncontrolled growth and movement cancer.
Cofre says: "Cancer isn't a glitch; it's the original software that built the first animals."
The Story of the First "Benign Tumor"
1. The Sticky Glue (Cadherins)
Imagine a group of people at a party who decide to form a dance circle. To stay in the circle, they have to hold hands.
- In the paper: Single-celled organisms used molecules called cadherins to stick to each other.
- The Analogy: Before they could become a complex animal, these cells had to "learn" to stay together without losing their ability to move. Cofre suggests the first embryo looked a bit like a benign tumor—a clump of cells that were happily growing and sticking together, but hadn't yet learned to stop moving when they needed to.
2. The Muscle Tension (Actin Cytoskeleton)
Once the cells stuck together, they needed to move as a team.
- In the paper: Cells use a skeleton made of actin to pull and push.
- The Analogy: Think of a group of people pulling a heavy rope together. In the first embryo, these cells pulled on each other to change shape. This pulling force is what allowed the embryo to stretch out and cover itself (a process called epiboly).
- The Cancer Connection: Cancer cells are famous for pulling on their surroundings to invade new areas. Cofre says the first animals used this same "pulling" power to build their bodies.
3. The Construction Site (The Extracellular Matrix)
You can't build a house without a foundation and scaffolding.
- In the paper: Cells secrete a gel-like substance called the Extracellular Matrix (ECM).
- The Analogy: Imagine the cells are construction workers. They lay down a sticky, stretchy floor (the ECM). As they walk on it, the floor changes texture. Some parts get hard, some get soft.
- The Magic: The cells can "feel" how hard or soft the floor is.
- If the floor is soft (like brain tissue), the cells decide to become neurons.
- If the floor is stiff (like bone), they decide to become bone cells.
- Cancer Connection: Cancer cells are masters at breaking down and remodeling this floor to make their own path. The first animals used this same skill to organize themselves into different body parts.
The Two "Great Revolutions"
Cofre describes two massive shifts that turned a blob of cells into a complex animal:
Revolution 1: The Stretch (Epiboly)
Imagine a balloon being inflated. The surface stretches out to cover the inside.
- The first cells used their internal muscles to stretch out and wrap around the embryo. This required them to stick together tightly while pulling hard. This is the same physical force cancer cells use to spread.
Revolution 2: The Remodeling (ECM & Differentiation)
Once the balloon was stretched, the cells needed to become different things (skin, gut, nerves).
- They did this by changing the "floor" they were standing on. They used enzymes (like molecular scissors) to cut and rearrange the sticky floor.
- The Result: The physical tension and the changing floor told the cells, "Okay, you are now a muscle cell," or "You are now a nerve cell."
- The Twist: In cancer, these scissors go crazy, cutting the floor everywhere and letting cells run wild. In the embryo, these scissors were carefully controlled to build a body.
Why Does This Matter?
1. We are looking at our history in the mirror.
Cofre suggests that when we look at a cancer cell, we aren't just seeing a disease. We are seeing a time machine. The cancer cell is remembering how the very first animal embryo moved, stuck together, and changed shape millions of years ago. It's an "evolutionary throwback" to the moment life went from single cells to groups.
2. Physics is the Architect.
Most people think genes (DNA) are the only bosses of the body. Cofre argues that physics (forces, tension, pressure) is just as important.
- Analogy: Think of DNA as the recipe for a cake. But physics is the oven and the hands mixing the batter. If you don't have the right heat and pressure, the cake won't rise, no matter how good the recipe is. The first animals were built by physical forces, and cancer is what happens when those forces get out of control.
3. A New Way to Cure Cancer.
If cancer is just the "embryo engine" running wild, maybe we can't just "kill" it. Instead, we need to understand how the embryo controls it.
- The Solution: Instead of just blasting cancer with poison, we should look at how the embryo uses "brakes" (like the Hippo pathway) to tell the engine when to stop. By understanding how the first animals learned to control their growth, we might learn how to teach cancer cells to behave again.
The Bottom Line
This paper proposes that cancer and embryology are two sides of the same coin.
- Embryos are the result of cells learning to grow, move, and stick together in a controlled way.
- Cancer is what happens when those same ancient tools are used without the controls.
The first animal didn't appear by magic; it appeared because a group of single cells decided to cooperate using the very same "aggressive" tools that cause cancer today. By studying cancer, we are actually studying the birth of animal life.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.