Test of lepton flavor universality with and decays at Belle II
Using 387 million decays collected by the Belle II detector, this study presents the most precise hadronic-tagging determination of the lepton flavor universality ratios and , yielding results consistent with both Standard Model predictions and previous measurements.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
In the subatomic world, nature appears to follow a strict rule of equality known as lepton flavor universality. This principle suggests that the fundamental forces of the universe treat three specific types of particles—electrons, muons, and tau particles—exactly the same way, differing only in their mass. Imagine three runners of different weights competing in a race where the wind resistance is identical for all; if the wind represents the fundamental force, the rule states that the wind should push each runner with the same strength relative to their mass, regardless of who they are. For decades, physicists have tested this rule, and it has held up in almost every experiment. However, a persistent hint of trouble has emerged in the decay of particles called B mesons. When these particles break apart, they sometimes produce a tau particle instead of a lighter electron or muon. Early measurements suggested this happened more often than the standard rules of physics predicted, hinting that the tau particle might be receiving a special boost from a hidden force or a new particle that the current theories do not account for.
A team of researchers using the Belle II detector at the SuperKEKB collider in Japan has now taken a fresh, highly precise look at this puzzle. They analyzed data from nearly four hundred million collisions between electrons and positrons, which created a vast number of B mesons. To isolate the specific events they needed, the scientists used a technique called hadronic tagging. This involved fully reconstructing one of the two B mesons produced in a collision by tracking all its decay products into a complex spray of other particles. Once this "tag" particle was identified, the researchers knew exactly what the other B meson in the event should have been, allowing them to focus on its decay with great precision. They looked for cases where this second B meson decayed into a charm meson and either a tau particle or a lighter lepton, while also producing invisible particles called neutrinos that carry away energy without leaving a trace in the detector.
The challenge in this experiment was that the neutrinos could not be seen directly. Instead, the team measured the energy that remained in the detector after accounting for all the visible particles and calculated the mass of the missing pieces. By studying the patterns of this missing energy and mass across thousands of events, they could distinguish between decays involving the heavy tau particle and those involving the lighter electrons or muons. The analysis revealed that the ratio of decays producing tau particles to those producing lighter leptons was consistent with the predictions of the standard model of physics. Specifically, they measured the ratio for decays involving a D* meson to be 0.242, with a small margin of error, and the ratio for decays involving a D meson to be 0.439. These numbers align closely with what the standard model expects, suggesting that the earlier hints of a violation might have been due to statistical fluctuations or uncertainties in previous measurements rather than a discovery of new physics.
This result is significant because it represents the most precise determination of these ratios using the hadronic tagging method to date. While the measurements are consistent with the standard model, they do not completely rule out the possibility of new physics, as the uncertainties are still large enough to allow for some deviation. The researchers found that their results agree with the standard model within a range of less than two standard deviations for the D meson ratio and even closer for the D* meson ratio. When combined with other measurements from around the world, the data still shows a slight tension with the standard model, but this new, more precise measurement from Belle II helps to clarify the picture. It suggests that if new physics exists, it is hiding in a more subtle way than previously thought, or that the earlier discrepancies were indeed just statistical noise. The work stands as a testament to the power of precise measurement in particle physics, where even a confirmation of the known rules helps to narrow the search for the unknown.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.