Recent CLFV searches at Belle and Belle II
This paper reviews the latest results from the Belle and Belle II experiments searching for charged lepton flavor violation (CLFV) in lepton, meson, and bottomonium decays, which are predicted by various new physics models to occur at rates accessible to current experiments despite being unobservably rare in the minimal Standard Model extension with massive neutrinos.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
In the universe of subatomic particles, there is a set of rules known as the Standard Model that dictates how matter behaves. One of these rules is a strict conservation of "flavor," a property that distinguishes different types of particles called leptons, such as electrons and muons. In the standard version of this theory, these particles are not allowed to change their identity; an electron cannot simply turn into a muon, nor can a muon vanish and reappear as an electron. This rule holds because the theory originally assumed that the particles' cousins, the neutrinos, had no mass. However, scientists have since discovered that neutrinos do have mass, which means the universe is not quite as rigid as once thought. While this discovery allows for tiny, almost impossible-to-detect changes in flavor under specific conditions, the Standard Model predicts that such changes should be so rare that they would never be seen in a human lifetime. If researchers could find a particle changing its flavor at a rate we can actually measure, it would be a clear signal that the current rules are incomplete and that new, undiscovered physics is at work.
This is the precise question that a team of physicists from the Belle and Belle II collaborations set out to answer. Operating a massive particle collider in Japan, they have been smashing electrons and positrons together to create a flood of heavy particles, including tau leptons, B mesons, and bottomonium states. These collisions act as a high-speed factory, producing billions of these particles so that scientists can watch them decay and look for the forbidden flavor changes. The researchers analyzed a vast collection of data, representing the largest samples of its kind ever gathered, to hunt for signs that a tau lepton or a B meson had spontaneously transformed into a different type of lepton. They looked for specific decay patterns, such as a tau turning into a muon and a flash of light, or a B meson splitting into a kaon and two different types of leptons. They also searched for more exotic possibilities, like a tau decaying into a lepton and a mysterious invisible particle, or bottomonium particles breaking apart into mismatched pairs of electrons and muons.
After sifting through the data with sophisticated computer algorithms designed to separate the rare signal from the overwhelming background noise, the researchers found nothing. In every single channel they examined, the number of events they observed matched exactly what would be expected from known physics, with no extra signals appearing to suggest new forces or particles. For instance, when they looked for a tau lepton turning into a muon and a photon, they saw nineteen events, which was consistent with the sixteen events predicted by background processes. Similarly, searches for taus decaying into three charged particles, or B mesons turning into a kaon and a tau-muon pair, yielded no evidence of the forbidden transformations. The team calculated the maximum possible rate at which these events could occur without being detected, setting the strictest limits yet on how often these flavor changes might happen. These limits are incredibly small, effectively ruling out many popular theories that predicted these decays would happen frequently enough to be seen.
The study also extended its search to the bottomonium family of particles, which are bound states of a bottom quark and its antiparticle. By examining how these particles decay, the team looked for signs of new interactions that could cause a bottomonium state to split into an electron and a muon, or an electron and a tau. They analyzed the recoil mass of the particles produced in these decays to see if a new particle was hiding in the data. Once again, the results were null. The data showed no deviation from the Standard Model, meaning that if new physics exists in the form of these specific flavor-changing interactions, it is happening at a rate far lower than current experiments can detect. The researchers also used these null results to constrain the mathematical parameters that describe potential new physics, narrowing the window of possibilities for future theories.
The significance of this work lies not in what was found, but in what was ruled out. By pushing the boundaries of sensitivity with such a large dataset, the Belle and Belle II collaborations have demonstrated that the universe is even more obedient to the Standard Model's rules than previously suspected. While the discovery of neutrino mass proved that lepton flavor is not perfectly conserved, these results show that the violation is not happening in the ways predicted by many new theories. The absence of a signal is a powerful result; it tells theorists that they must look elsewhere for the next great breakthrough in understanding the fundamental laws of nature. As the Belle II experiment continues to collect more data, the search will become even more precise, but for now, the silence of the detectors stands as a testament to the robustness of our current understanding of the subatomic world.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.