Cross-level correlation and temporal dynamics of hierarchical habitat selection
This study on European hares reveals that habitat selection operates through a hierarchical strategy where stable, large-scale home range placement coexists with flexible, fine-scale habitat use that dynamically responds to seasonal environmental changes, with the correlation between these selection levels varying significantly depending on the specific habitat type.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of a preprint that has not been peer-reviewed. It is not medical advice. Do not make health decisions based on this content. Read full disclaimer
For any animal that moves, the world is not a single, flat stage but a series of nested choices. An animal first decides where to live on a broad scale, picking a general neighborhood that offers the right mix of food and safety. Once that neighborhood is chosen, it makes smaller, daily decisions about exactly where to walk, rest, or eat within those boundaries. Scientists have long known that these choices happen in layers, with the big decision shaping the small one. But a lingering question has been whether these layers work in lockstep. Does a strong preference for a certain type of land at the big scale mean the animal will also seek it out intensely at the small scale? Or does the animal compensate, seeking that same land less intensely once it has secured a home range that already contains it? Understanding this relationship is vital for conservation, especially for species like the European hare, whose populations are struggling across much of its native range. If we do not know how these different levels of choice interact, we might manage the landscape in a way that satisfies the animal's need for a home but fails to meet its daily needs, or vice versa.
To untangle this, researchers tracked fifty-two European hares in the mid-mountain grasslands of the French Jura between 2021 and 2023. These were not wild-born animals but individuals raised in captivity and released as part of a reinforcement program, all fitted with GPS collars that recorded their location once an hour. The scientists used this data to look at two distinct levels of decision-making. The first level was where the hares placed their home ranges within the wider landscape. The second level was how they used the specific patches of land inside those home ranges. By comparing the strength of the hares' preferences for different habitats—such as grasslands, forests, or farm tracks—at both levels over time, the team could see if the choices reinforced each other, opposed each other, or moved independently.
The results revealed that there is no single rule that applies to all habitats. For some types of land, the hares' choices at the two levels moved in the same direction. When the hares selected grasslands, forests, or farm tracks more strongly at the landscape level, they also tended to use them more intensively within their home ranges. This suggests that for these stable, high-value resources, the animal's desire is consistent regardless of the scale. However, the story changed completely for fodder crops. For this specific habitat, the relationship was negative. When the hares selected fodder crops more strongly to include in their home range, they actually used them less intensively once inside that range. The researchers suggest this happens because fodder crops are patchy and scarce; by ensuring a home range contains them, the hare secures access, but then does not need to seek them out as aggressively within the boundaries it has already established.
The study also uncovered how the hares reacted to the changing weather. The choices made at the landscape level were remarkably stable, showing little response to short-term shifts in temperature or rainfall. The hares seemed to pick their neighborhoods based on long-term needs, sticking to their chosen areas even as the seasons turned. In contrast, their daily movements inside those neighborhoods were highly flexible. When temperatures rose or rains fell, the hares adjusted their use of specific habitats within their home ranges. For instance, on warmer days, they were more likely to use open fields and farm tracks, while wetter conditions drove them toward forests and forest edges, likely seeking shelter. This indicates that while the hares hold onto their home ranges as a stable foundation, they constantly tweak their daily behavior to match the immediate conditions of the day.
The researchers also tested whether an animal's loyalty to its home range affected these patterns. They wondered if hares that stayed in the same spot for longer periods would have less flexibility in their choices, forcing a disconnect between the big and small scales. The data did not support this idea. Even the most faithful hares, those that barely moved their home ranges from one season to the next, still showed the ability to adjust their habitat use within those boundaries. This suggests that the ability to make fine-scale adjustments is a separate skill from the decision of where to live, allowing the animal to remain flexible in its daily life even when its overall location is fixed.
Ultimately, the study paints a picture of a species that relies on a strategy of stability and flexibility. The European hare secures its future by choosing a home range that offers a reliable mix of resources, a decision that remains steady over time. Within that secure boundary, it remains agile, shifting its daily habits to cope with the weather and the immediate availability of food. For conservationists, this means that saving the hare requires more than just protecting a single type of habitat. It requires maintaining a landscape that is a mosaic of different environments, allowing the animal to make its broad choices while retaining the freedom to adapt its daily life to the changing world around it.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.