Structural Equation Modelling: Basis for a Proposed Framework on Construction Engineering Management
This study utilizes Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) on data from 309 construction professionals in Caraga, Philippines, to examine factors associated with perceived project success and propose a region-specific five-level Construction Engineering Management Maturity Framework (CEM-MF) for enhancing sector performance.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
Construction projects are the physical backbone of modern society, turning blueprints into bridges, hospitals, and homes. Yet, building something large is rarely a simple act of stacking materials; it is a complex dance of managing people, money, time, and technology, all while navigating unpredictable weather, shifting regulations, and the needs of many different groups. In the Caraga region of the Philippines, a place rich in natural resources but facing significant infrastructure challenges, these pressures are felt acutely. The question facing engineers and managers there is not just how to build, but how to build well. To answer this, researchers turned to a method that treats a construction project like a living system, where every decision ripples through the entire operation. They wanted to understand which specific habits and tools are associated with a successful project, and whether the way a company is organized—working for the government or for a private business—changes the outcome.
The researchers focused on five key areas that influence how a project turns out. First, they looked at the daily habits of planning and organizing, such as setting clear goals and monitoring progress. Second, they examined how well teams manage their resources, including workers, money, and equipment. Third, they studied the use of modern technology, like digital models and data tools, to keep everyone on the same page. Fourth, they considered how well project leaders talk to and involve everyone with a stake in the work, from local officials to the people who will eventually use the building. Finally, they measured the external pressures that are outside a team's control, such as economic shifts, political changes, or difficult weather. By surveying 309 construction professionals across the region, the team mapped out how these factors connected to the final result: whether a project was perceived as being completed on time, within budget, and to a high standard of quality.
The study found several associations between these factors and project outcomes. Resource management, technological integration, project management practices, and stakeholder engagement were positively associated with perceived project success, while external influences were negatively associated with it.
However, the researchers discovered a sharp divide between the public and private sectors. The professionals working for private companies reported significantly higher levels of success and stronger management capabilities across the board. They felt they had better control over their resources, used technology more effectively, and engaged stakeholders more successfully than their counterparts in government agencies. The public sector respondents, meanwhile, reported facing much higher levels of external pressure, likely due to the complex web of regulations and bureaucratic processes they navigate daily. This gap suggests that while the private sector has developed robust internal systems, the public sector is often weighed down by the very environment it operates in, struggling to maintain the same level of control and efficiency.
Despite these clear patterns, the researchers were careful to temper their conclusions with a note of caution. The statistical tools they used to measure these relationships showed that the survey questions themselves might not have perfectly separated the different concepts. In simpler terms, the way the questions were asked made it difficult to say with absolute certainty that "resource management" is a completely distinct thing from "technological integration" in the minds of the respondents. Because of this, the researchers did not claim to have found a perfect, unchangeable formula for success. Instead, they proposed a practical framework, a kind of maturity scale, to help organizations assess where they stand. This framework divides management capability into five levels, from "lower" to "leading," based on the scores of the professionals surveyed. It allows a company to see if it is merely emerging in its practices or if it has reached an advanced stage, providing a clear path for improvement.
Ultimately, this work offers a realistic map for the construction industry in Caraga. It suggests that while technology is associated with success, it exists alongside the need for solid resource management and clear planning. It highlights that the private sector's success may stem from its ability to operate with fewer external constraints, while the public sector needs strategies to better navigate the complex web of regulations and community expectations. The proposed maturity framework gives these organizations a way to measure their own progress, not against a distant ideal, but against their own current reality. By understanding where they stand, construction leaders can make informed decisions about where to focus their efforts, whether that means improving how they track materials, investing in better digital tools, or finding new ways to communicate with the communities they serve.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.