"Who would I tell?" Disclosure of child sexual abuse in India: a systematic review
This systematic review of 13 studies in India reveals that child sexual abuse disclosure is significantly hindered by shame, fear, family gatekeeping, and institutional disbelief, while being facilitated by trusted support, underscoring the need for systemic interventions rather than placing the burden solely on children.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
For a child who has been hurt, the moment of speaking out is often the most difficult step they will ever take. In the study of child sexual abuse, researchers have long understood that silence is not a sign that the abuse did not happen, but rather a complex reaction to fear, shame, and the confusing dynamics of family life. When a child is harmed, they often wait, hoping the pain will stop or fearing that speaking up will make things worse. They may worry that no one will believe them, or that telling the truth will break their family apart. In many parts of the world, including India, the path from a private secret to a public report is blocked by these heavy emotional walls and by the reactions of the adults around them. Understanding how children navigate this path, and why so many remain silent, is essential for building systems that actually protect them.
A new systematic review brings together evidence from across India to answer a simple but urgent question: who do children tell when they are abused, and what stops them from speaking? The researchers gathered and analyzed thirteen different studies involving thousands of children, adolescents, and adult survivors. They looked at data from schools, hospitals, and community surveys to map out the journey of disclosure. What they found is a landscape where silence is the norm, not the exception. In the studies that measured it, a significant portion of children never told anyone about the abuse they suffered. In one group of schoolgirls in Delhi, nearly half had never spoken up. In another sample from Puducherry, the number of children who remained silent was even higher, reaching over sixty percent in one group. The silence was not random; it grew deeper as the abuse became more severe. When children were forced to fondle another person, the rate of non-disclosure climbed to over ninety percent, and in cases where they were forced to pose for nude photographs, every single child in that group kept the secret.
The reasons for this silence are deeply rooted in the child's own feelings and their perception of the world. Shame was the most common barrier, a heavy sense of embarrassment that made children feel they could not speak. Alongside shame was a profound fear of what would happen if they did tell. Children worried they would be blamed, that their families would be ruined, or that they would be punished. In some cases, they felt a strange loyalty to the person who hurt them, especially when that person was a family member or a neighbor they knew well. Some children simply did not have the words to describe what happened to them, or they were groomed into believing that the abuse was normal. One study of men who had been abused as boys noted that they grew up in environments where sex was never discussed, leaving them without a vocabulary to name their own victimization.
Even when a child does find the courage to speak, the journey often stalls before it reaches the people who can offer legal protection or medical help. The review found that almost no child reached the formal police or court system on their own. Instead, the decision to report often rested with the family, who acted as gatekeepers. In many instances, families chose to keep the matter inside the home. Sometimes, the motivation for reporting was not the child's safety, but the family's honour or pride. In one large study of forensic cases, the majority of reports were made by parents whose stated intent was to protect the family's honour or pride, while only a small fraction sought punishment for the assailant. When families did not report, the child was left without a way to access the support systems designed to help them.
When children did turn to friends or teachers, they often met with responses that discouraged further action. Teachers, who are designated as mandatory reporters under Indian law, frequently lacked awareness of the child protection policy and the know-how to act. Some questioned the child's story, asked why they were telling the story now, or worried about the school's reputation. In hospitals, some staff minimized the abuse or assumed that boys would simply grow out of the experience. The result was a pattern where a child might tell a trusted adult, only to be met with disbelief, silence, or a warning to keep quiet. The few times that children received consistent support, it was because a specific, familiar adult stayed with them through the entire process, acting as a bridge between the child and the official systems.
The researchers conclude that the problem is not a lack of willingness on the part of children to speak, but a lack of readiness on the part of the adults and institutions around them. The evidence suggests that waiting for a child to volunteer the information is rarely successful. Instead, the most effective way to uncover abuse is for a trusted adult to ask directly, privately, and sensitively. However, even when a child is asked and does tell, the system often fails to follow through. The review indicates that fixing this issue requires more than just teaching children to speak up. It demands that families be engaged as partners who can choose to act in the child's best interest, and that schools and hospitals be equipped with the skills and support to respond with belief and action. Until these adult gatekeepers are prepared to listen and act, the silence of many children will likely continue.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.