Booster or Barrier? Meritocratic Beliefs and Chinese Youth’s Subjective Well-being: Parallel Mediating Roles of Self-efficacy and Subjective Social Status, and Gender Heterogeneity
Drawing on CFPS data and PLS-SEM analysis, this study reveals that meritocratic beliefs act as a "booster" for Chinese youth's subjective well-being through the parallel mediation of self-efficacy and subjective social status, with distinct gender-specific mechanisms where self-efficacy drives outcomes more strongly for males while subjective social status plays a compensatory, fully mediating role for females.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
In the landscape of human psychology, few concepts are as deeply woven into the fabric of society as the idea that hard work leads to success. This belief, often called meritocracy, suggests that social standing and rewards are distributed based on ability and effort rather than luck or family connections. For young people navigating a competitive world, holding this belief can feel like a compass: it promises that if they push forward, they will arrive somewhere meaningful. However, the relationship between this belief and a person's happiness is complex. In some places, believing that the system is fair can be a source of stress, leading individuals to blame themselves when they struggle. In others, it can be a source of strength, providing a sense of control and purpose. Understanding whether this belief acts as a boost to happiness or a barrier to it is crucial, especially for a generation facing intense social pressure.
A recent study by Zan Li, a researcher at the China Youth University of Political Studies, tackles this question directly within the context of contemporary China. The research focuses on Chinese youth, a group currently facing a well-documented crisis in subjective well-being, which is simply a person's overall assessment of how happy and satisfied they feel with their life. The study asks a fundamental question: For young people in China today, does believing that hard work pays off make them happier, or does it make them feel worse? To find the answer, the researcher analyzed data from the China Family Panel Studies, a massive, nationally representative survey that tracks the lives of thousands of households. By looking at the responses of over 3,000 young adults aged 18 to 44, the study mapped out not just the direct link between these beliefs and happiness, but also the hidden pathways that connect them.
The investigation revealed a clear and somewhat surprising result. Contrary to the idea that meritocratic beliefs might be a source of pressure or a barrier to happiness, the data showed that for Chinese youth, these beliefs act as a booster. Young people who strongly believe that effort and ability determine success report higher levels of happiness. This finding challenges the notion that such beliefs are inherently negative in a competitive environment. Instead, the study suggests that in China's unique cultural setting, where a long history of valuing hard work and education exists, believing in meritocracy provides a psychological resource. It helps young people feel that their lives have meaning and that their efforts are not in vain.
But how does this belief actually translate into feeling happier? The study uncovered two distinct mental pathways that explain this process. The first pathway involves what psychologists call self-efficacy, which is a person's confidence in their own ability to handle challenges and shape their future. When young people believe in meritocracy, they tend to feel more capable and in control of their lives. This increased confidence, in turn, lifts their overall happiness. The second pathway relates to subjective social status, which is simply how a person perceives their own standing in society compared to others. Believing in meritocracy helps young people feel that their current position is deserved and earned through their own efforts. This sense of earned status protects them from negative feelings like relative deprivation, where one feels unfairly treated compared to peers, thereby supporting their well-being.
The research also looked closely at whether these effects play out differently for men and women, a factor known as gender heterogeneity. The results showed a distinct split in how these pathways function. For young men, the belief in meritocracy boosts happiness through both direct confidence and the sense of earned status, but the confidence pathway is particularly strong. It appears that for men, who often face traditional expectations to be the primary earners and achievers, the link between believing in hard work and feeling capable is very direct and powerful. For young women, the picture is slightly different. While they also benefit from the belief, the direct link to confidence is weaker. Instead, the belief in meritocracy helps them feel happier primarily by reinforcing their sense of social standing. In a way, for women, the belief that the system is fair serves as a compensatory mechanism; when the direct boost to confidence is less pronounced, the feeling that their social position is legitimate and deserved takes on a greater role in maintaining their happiness.
This study does more than just measure happiness scores; it clarifies the mechanics of how a cultural value interacts with individual psychology. It shows that while the pressure of competition is real, the underlying belief that the system rewards effort is not the enemy of happiness for Chinese youth. Instead, it is a vital part of their mental toolkit. The findings suggest that for men, fostering a sense of personal agency and capability is key to leveraging this belief for well-being. For women, ensuring that their social contributions are recognized and that they feel their status is secure is equally important. By understanding these different routes to happiness, the study offers a nuanced view of how young people in a rapidly changing society find meaning and satisfaction in their lives. It confirms that in this specific cultural context, the belief that hard work matters is not a trap, but a foundation for a good life.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.