Required interventions in open drug scenes: A mixed method study in Tehran, Iran
This mixed-method study in Tehran identifies a need to shift from coercive drug policies toward integrated, context-specific interventions that balance harm reduction, rehabilitation, and community engagement, while highlighting the feasibility of strategies like expanded drop-in centers and peer-led support alongside contextual barriers to approaches such as supervised consumption rooms.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
In many cities around the world, there are specific public corners where people gather to buy, sell, and use illegal drugs. These places, often called open drug scenes, create a difficult environment for everyone nearby. They bring health risks, such as the spread of disease through shared needles or discarded trash, and social problems like crime, violence, and fear among neighbors. For decades, governments have tried to fix these problems, often by sending police to clear the streets or by forcing people into treatment centers. However, these strict measures do not always stop the drug use from happening, and they often push the problem into darker, less visible corners. The challenge for communities is finding a way to balance public safety with the health and dignity of the people who use drugs, recognizing that simply removing the people does not remove the underlying issues.
A team of researchers in Tehran, Iran, set out to understand what actually works to manage these difficult public spaces. They focused on the gap between the harsh laws currently in place and the practical needs of the people living and working in these areas. In Iran, the law treats drug use as a crime unless the person is already in treatment, often leading to forced confinement in camps. Despite these strict rules, drug scenes persist. To find better solutions, the researchers did not just look at statistics; they listened to the people involved. They spoke with twenty-five key individuals, including nine people who use drugs, seven service providers who work with them, and representatives from the police and local government. They asked a simple but profound question: what interventions are actually needed to reduce the harm caused by these open drug scenes?
The researchers found that the people they spoke with had very different ideas about the solution. The people who use drugs emphasized that they needed basic rights and support, such as help getting official identification papers so they could find work, and safe places to use their drugs without fear of arrest. They argued that if the government provided regulated access to substances, people would not need to steal or commit crimes to get them. In contrast, the police officers, who often deal with angry neighbors, believed the main goal should be to completely eliminate these drug scenes from the streets. The service providers, who work directly with the users, saw a middle path: they wanted to empower people through rehabilitation and health services, but they also recognized the need for immediate safety measures.
To turn these diverse opinions into a clear plan, the researchers brought together a group of fourteen experts for a second round of discussion. This group included university professors, service providers, and three people who use drugs. They reviewed a long list of possible solutions and rated them based on two things: how likely they were to work in the current Iranian context, and how effective they would be at solving the problem. This process helped them separate ideas that sounded good in theory from those that could actually be done on the ground.
The experts agreed on several strategies that were both practical and effective. They strongly supported expanding the hours that drop-in centers stay open, so people have a safe place to go for longer periods. They also favored hiring peers—people who have lived experience with addiction—to lead support groups and interventions, as these individuals can build trust more easily than outsiders. Another highly rated idea was to build rehabilitation centers right next to harm reduction facilities, creating a seamless path from immediate safety to long-term recovery. The group also agreed that police should shift their focus from simply arresting people to acting as partners in public health, perhaps by using specially trained officers to handle situations involving children or to connect people with care instead of jail.
The study also highlighted the importance of the physical environment and community education. Experts suggested improving the quality of the streets in these areas and teaching residents how to separate their recyclable waste, which would allow people who use drugs to collect and sell recyclables instead of digging through garbage bins. Raising public awareness about infectious diseases like hepatitis was also seen as a vital step to reduce fear and stigma among neighbors.
However, the experts also ruled out several popular ideas as being too difficult to implement in Iran right now. Strategies such as creating supervised rooms where people can use drugs under medical supervision, or providing government-prescribed drugs to users, received low scores for feasibility. Similarly, the idea of moving treatment centers far away from residential areas, which many neighbors wanted, was seen as counterproductive because it makes it harder for people to access help. The "housing first" approach, which gives people a home before asking them to get clean, was also rated as less feasible in the current context, likely due to legal and cultural barriers.
The researchers concluded that the most effective way forward is not to choose between law enforcement and health care, but to integrate them. They found that a successful strategy requires a mix of policing that protects the community, social support that restores dignity, and education that builds understanding. The study suggests that for these solutions to work, everyone involved—from the police officer to the person using drugs—must be seen as a member of the community with both rights and responsibilities. While the current system in Iran relies heavily on punishment, the evidence points toward a future where health-oriented, community-based models take the lead, offering a more sustainable path to safety and recovery.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.