Coexistence of KIF21A-related congenital fibrosis of the extraocular muscles type 1 and GJB2 p.Arg75Trp-related hearing loss: a family case report
This case report describes an 8-year-old girl with a dual molecular diagnosis of KIF21A-related congenital fibrosis of the extraocular muscles type 1 and GJB2-related hearing loss, highlighting the importance of considering multiple genetic etiologies when clinical features cannot be explained by a single disorder and underscoring specific surgical risks for ptosis management in such patients.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
Human bodies are complex machines where different systems operate on their own blueprints, yet they often work in concert to create a single, functioning person. Sometimes, however, a person inherits two separate instructions from their parents that happen to affect different parts of the body at the same time. One set of instructions might govern how the eyes move, while another controls how the ears hear. When these two distinct genetic stories collide in one child, it creates a medical puzzle that looks like a single, complicated condition but is actually two independent stories happening side by side. Understanding this requires looking past the surface of a patient's symptoms to see the specific genetic codes they carry, a task that has become possible only recently with advanced tools that can read the entire library of human genes.
In a recent report from a hospital in Shanxi, China, researchers described just such a case involving an eight-year-old girl. She had been born with eyes that did not move normally and ears that could not hear. To the casual observer, these might seem like symptoms of one large, mysterious syndrome. However, a deep genetic investigation revealed that she was carrying two separate, dominant genetic variants, one inherited from her mother and one from her father. Each variant was responsible for a completely different set of symptoms, creating a situation where the child had two distinct medical diagnoses at once.
The girl's eyes presented a condition known as congenital fibrosis of the extraocular muscles. This is a rare disorder where the muscles that move the eye are stuck in place from birth, not because they are scarred, but because the nerves that tell them to move never developed correctly. As a result, the girl was born with her eyelids drooping heavily, a condition called ptosis, and her eyes were restricted in all directions of movement, with the limitation being more prominent in the vertical direction. She could not look up, down, left, or right freely. To see, she had to tilt her head back and lift her chin. When the doctors tried to see if her eyes would roll up when she looked down—a natural reflex that protects the eye called the Bell's phenomenon—it was completely absent. This meant that if her eyelids were lifted to improve her vision, her eyes would be exposed to the air without the usual protective reflex, putting her cornea at risk of drying out and getting damaged.
At the same time, the girl had profound hearing loss. Her ears could not detect sound at almost any level, and tests showed that the inner part of her ear, which converts sound waves into nerve signals, was not working. She also had thick, rough skin on the palms of her hands and the soles of her feet, a condition that looked like a skin disorder known as palmoplantar keratoderma. While these symptoms—eye movement issues, deafness, and thick skin—might suggest a single, complex genetic syndrome, the researchers suspected that two different genetic causes were at play.
To find the answer, the team used a powerful technology called whole-exome sequencing. This method reads the specific parts of the DNA that contain instructions for making proteins, which are the building blocks of the body. They tested the girl and both of her parents. The results were clear and distinct. The girl had inherited a specific change in a gene called KIF21A from her mother. This gene is known to control the development of the eye muscles. Her mother and her maternal grandfather also carried this same change and had the same eye problems, confirming that this single genetic error was responsible for the girl's inability to move her eyes and her drooping eyelids.
Simultaneously, the girl had inherited a different genetic change from her father. This change was in a gene called GJB2, which is famous for its role in hearing. This specific variant is known to cause hearing loss and can sometimes lead to thickening of the skin on the hands and feet. The girl's father had a history of severe hearing loss since childhood, though he had never been formally tested. The girl's profound deafness and her skin changes matched the known effects of this second gene. The researchers confirmed that the girl did not have a single disease that caused all her symptoms. Instead, she had two separate, dominant genetic conditions inherited from different parents.
This finding is significant because it changes how doctors should approach treatment. If a doctor assumed the girl had one single syndrome, they might miss the specific risks associated with each part. For instance, the eye condition requires careful planning before any surgery to lift the eyelids. Because the girl lacks the protective eye-rolling reflex and her eyelids do not close completely, lifting the lids could leave her cornea exposed to air and light, leading to permanent damage. The researchers emphasized that surgeons must be aware of this specific combination of absent reflexes and incomplete closure before operating.
The case also highlights the power of modern genetic testing. In the past, a patient with multiple symptoms might have been given a broad, uncertain diagnosis. Today, by reading the genetic code, doctors can see that a patient is carrying two independent instructions. One instruction explains the eyes, and the other explains the ears and skin. This distinction is not just academic; it ensures that the family understands the inheritance pattern correctly and that the patient receives care that addresses each specific risk. The girl's story serves as a reminder that the human body can carry multiple genetic narratives at once, and only by reading them all can we truly understand the whole picture.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.