Social Comparison and Well-Being: When Others’ Success Inspires Rather Than Threatens
Across three studies, this research demonstrates that inspiration serves as a critical mediating mechanism through which benign envy and social network heterogeneity reduce state anxiety, whereas malicious envy increases anxiety by diminishing inspiration.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
Every day, we look at the lives of others and measure our own against them. When a former classmate lands a dream job or a neighbor buys a new home, that moment of comparison can feel like a heavy weight, sparking feelings of inadequacy or worry. Yet, the same sight can also light a fire, making us feel energized and eager to improve our own circumstances. This dual nature of looking up to someone else is a central puzzle in the study of human emotion. Scientists have long known that when we envy someone, it can take two distinct forms. One type is a bitter, resentful feeling that focuses on what we lack and what the other person has unfairly taken. The other is a more constructive feeling that acknowledges the other's success and uses it as a spark for our own growth. While researchers have studied these feelings separately, it remains unclear exactly how they shape our mental state or why some people find inspiration in others' achievements while others find only distress.
A team of researchers set out to untangle this relationship by examining three specific elements: the type of envy a person feels, the diversity of their close social circle, and a feeling called inspiration. They wanted to know if the way we feel about others' success is determined solely by our internal emotions, or if the people we surround ourselves with also play a role. To investigate this, they conducted three separate studies involving hundreds of American adults. In the first study, they asked participants to imagine a scenario where they had just accepted a difficult, low-paying job after a series of mixed results in school and sports. They then asked them to read about a former classmate who had achieved significant success in the same fields. The researchers measured how much the participants felt two different kinds of envy: a constructive desire to improve, and a resentful wish to see the other person fail. They also measured how anxious the participants felt in that moment. The results were clear: the resentful kind of envy was strongly linked to higher anxiety, while the constructive kind showed no such link. This confirmed that not all envy is the same; one type threatens our peace of mind, while the other does not necessarily do so.
The second study added a new layer to the investigation by introducing the concept of inspiration. The researchers asked the same question about envy but also measured whether the participants felt a sense of new possibility and motivation. They found that the constructive envy was strongly linked to feeling inspired, whereas the resentful envy was linked to feeling less inspired. Crucially, those who felt more inspired reported significantly lower levels of anxiety. The researchers then looked at the participants' social lives, specifically asking them to map out the composition of their close friends and family. They measured how many of these close ties belonged to people from different racial or economic backgrounds compared to the participant. They discovered that people with more diverse social networks, who had more friends from different backgrounds, reported feeling more inspired when they saw others succeed. This suggested that the people we know might change how we interpret the success of strangers.
In the third study, the researchers brought all these pieces together to see how they fit into a single picture. They again asked participants to view the success of others and reported on their feelings of envy, inspiration, and anxiety. They also measured how diverse the participants' social networks were. The data revealed a clear chain of events. Both the type of envy a person felt and the diversity of their social network influenced whether they felt inspired. In turn, feeling inspired was the key factor that lowered anxiety. The study showed that having a diverse group of close friends did not directly lower anxiety on its own; rather, it worked by making people more likely to feel inspired when they saw others succeed. The researchers also explored whether diverse networks changed how people saw the world. They found that people with more economically diverse networks tended to see a wider range of possible paths to success, which helped explain why they felt more inspired.
The findings suggest that the impact of seeing someone else succeed is not fixed. It depends on a combination of our immediate emotional reaction and the broader social environment we live in. When we feel a resentful envy, we are likely to feel anxious. When we feel a constructive envy, we are more likely to feel inspired, but only if that feeling actually takes hold. Furthermore, the people we choose to keep close matter. A social circle that includes people from different backgrounds seems to help us view others' achievements not as a threat, but as a sign that many different paths to success are possible. This does not mean that envy disappears or that everyone will feel inspired by success, but it points to a specific mechanism: inspiration acts as a bridge. It is the feeling that transforms the sight of another's success from a source of stress into a source of motivation. By understanding that our social networks can shape this feeling, we gain a clearer picture of why some people thrive on comparison while others struggle, and how the structure of our daily lives might help us navigate it.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.