Effectiveness of the TRAP-Guard Intervention on Perception of Traffic-Related Air Pollution and Face Cover Use Among Traffic Police in Klang Valley, Malaysia: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial
This cluster randomized controlled trial demonstrates that the TRAP-Guard intervention, based on the Health Belief Model, effectively improved traffic police officers' perceptions of traffic-related air pollution and initiated face cover use in Malaysia, although the behavioral change was not sustained at three months without continuous reinforcement.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written or endorsed by the authors. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
Every day, millions of people step into the flow of city traffic, but for traffic police officers, this environment is their workplace. They stand for hours in the open air, directing vehicles and managing congestion, which means they breathe in a steady stream of exhaust fumes and tiny particles from car engines. This mixture of pollutants, known as traffic-related air pollution, is a known hazard that can damage lungs and hearts over time. While many officers know these risks exist, knowing a danger is real does not always mean a person will take steps to protect themselves. Health experts often look to a framework called the Health Belief Model to understand why. This model suggests that a person's decision to act depends on several things: how likely they think they are to get sick, how serious they believe the consequences would be, whether they see real benefits in taking action, what obstacles they feel stand in their way, how confident they are in their ability to do it, and what reminders or cues push them to act. If any of these pieces are missing, even a well-informed person might skip wearing a protective mask.
In the Klang Valley of Malaysia, where traffic is dense and pollution levels can be high, researchers set out to test if a specific educational program could change the habits of traffic police officers. They designed a training module called TRAP-Guard, built directly on the Health Belief Model, to see if it could shift the officers' thinking and, more importantly, their behavior. The study involved 206 officers from various police stations in the area. The researchers divided these stations into two groups: one group received the new, detailed TRAP-Guard training, while the other group received a standard, shorter talk about general workplace health. The training for the first group was hands-on and interactive. It included videos and discussions about the specific risks of breathing in traffic fumes, practical demonstrations on how to wear a face mask correctly, and role-playing exercises to build confidence. The instructors also placed posters in the stations and asked supervisors to give daily reminders, creating a constant environment that encouraged safety. The goal was to see if this comprehensive approach would make officers more aware of their vulnerability and more likely to wear masks consistently.
The results showed that the training worked well to change how the officers thought about the problem. After the intervention, the officers who received the TRAP-Guard module felt significantly more aware that they were personally at risk of health problems from the pollution. They also became more convinced that wearing a mask was actually useful and felt much more confident in their ability to wear one correctly while doing their jobs. They reported fewer reasons for not wearing a mask, such as discomfort or difficulty communicating, and they were more responsive to the daily reminders and visual cues provided at their stations. These positive shifts in mindset were not just temporary; they remained strong even three months after the training ended. However, one part of their thinking did not change much: the officers already believed the health risks were severe before the study began, so the training could not make them feel any more serious about the danger.
When it came to the actual behavior of wearing face masks, the story was a mix of short-term success and long-term challenges. Immediately after the training, the officers in the intervention group started wearing masks much more often than those in the control group. This surge in action suggests that the combination of increased confidence, better understanding of the benefits, and the immediate presence of reminders was powerful enough to get them started. Yet, when the researchers checked again three months later, this improvement had faded. The officers were no longer wearing masks at significantly higher rates than the group that had received only the standard health talk. This finding indicates that while a well-designed educational program can successfully spark a change in behavior and improve how people perceive a risk, it may not be enough on its own to keep that behavior going over time. The initial boost from the training wore off, and without continuous reinforcement or perhaps changes to the work environment itself, the officers returned to their previous habits.
The study concludes that education is a vital first step. By using a structured approach that addresses confidence, perceived barriers, and reminders, organizations can effectively improve how workers view traffic pollution and get them to start using protective gear. However, the drop in mask usage after three months suggests that knowledge and a single training session are not a permanent fix. To maintain these protective habits, the researchers suggest that health programs need to be paired with ongoing support, such as regular refresher sessions, consistent supervision, and a reliable supply of equipment. The work of traffic police is demanding, and keeping them safe from the air they breathe requires more than just a one-time lesson; it requires a sustained effort to keep safety at the forefront of their daily routine.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.