Post-indexical postmemory: virtual reality and inaccessible trauma in Hayoun Kwon's practice
This article proposes the concept of "post-indexical postmemory" to theorize how Hayoun Kwon's virtual reality work, particularly *489 Years*, mediates inherited Korean diasporic trauma by foregrounding technological construction and evidentiary absence rather than relying on photographic indexicality, thereby extending Marianne Hirsch's postmemory theory beyond its Holocaust-centered, photograph-based origins into the realm of immersive computational media.
Original paper licensed under CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). This is an AI-generated explanation of the paper below. It is not written by the author. For technical accuracy, refer to the original paper. Read full disclaimer
Memory is often thought of as a collection of pictures we keep in our minds, but for the generation that comes after a great tragedy, memory works differently. They did not live through the event, yet they carry its weight. Scholars call this "postmemory," a way of inheriting the past through stories and images rather than direct experience. For decades, the most powerful tool for this inheritance was the photograph. A photograph has a unique power because it is a physical trace of light that once touched a real person or place; it proves that something happened. But what happens when there are no photographs? What if the place where the trauma occurred is a forbidden zone where cameras are not allowed, or if the story of a victim is rejected by authorities because there is no paper proof to back it up? This is the question that drives a new way of thinking about how we remember the past in a digital age.
A researcher named Changhee Han, based at Kangwon National University in South Korea, has been studying how artists are handling these impossible gaps in history. He focuses on the work of Hayoun Kwon, a Korean artist living in France who creates digital art about places and people that cannot be seen or proven in the usual way. Han argues that when we cannot rely on the old power of the photograph, we need a new kind of memory. He calls this "post-indexical postmemory." It is a way of remembering that admits it is a construction. Instead of trying to fake a perfect, realistic picture that looks like a photograph, these artists build digital spaces that look clearly made, using the very fact that they are artificial to tell the truth about the absence of evidence.
The central example Han examines is a virtual reality work called 489 Years, created by Kwon in 2016. The work takes the viewer into the Korean Demilitarized Zone, a heavily guarded strip of land separating North and South Korea that has been closed to civilians for over seventy years. Because no ordinary person can walk there, and because cameras are strictly forbidden in the inner zones, there are no photographs of the soldier's patrols or the landmines hidden in the grass. To build this experience, Kwon did not try to find a hidden photo. Instead, she interviewed a former South Korean soldier who had served there. She took his spoken words and, working with a video game designer, built a digital landscape based entirely on his memory.
When a person puts on a virtual reality headset to experience 489 Years, they do not see a photorealistic movie. They see a world made of simple, blocky shapes and flat colors, looking more like a rough sketch than a real place. The viewer can turn their head and look around, but they cannot touch anything or leave the zone. This design is intentional. By refusing to make the scene look real, the art forces the viewer to acknowledge that they are inside a story told by someone else, not a real place they are visiting. The lack of photographic detail does not weaken the memory; instead, it makes the viewer feel the distance between their own life and the soldier's experience. The work suggests that we can feel the weight of a place we have never seen, even if we know the image is a fabrication, because the story behind it is true.
Han contrasts this with another of Kwon's works, Lack of Evidence, made in 2011. This piece tells the story of a Nigerian refugee named Oscar, whose request for asylum in France was denied because he could not provide physical proof of the danger he fled. In this work, Kwon does not use a headset. Instead, she shows a video on a screen where Oscar and his brother are represented as transparent, wireframe skeletons moving through empty space. They have no skin, no clothes, and no solid bodies. This visual style matches the legal reality Oscar faced: the state said his story was not real because there was no proof. The art does not try to fill in the missing proof with a fake photo. Instead, it leaves the gaps visible. The wireframe figures show us that the story exists, but also that the evidence is missing. It is a way of saying that the memory is real, even if the proof is not.
The paper suggests that these works offer a new path for how we understand history when the usual records are gone. In the past, scholars believed that memory needed the anchor of a photograph to be valid. Han argues that Kwon's work shows we can have a powerful, ethical connection to the past even without that anchor. The key is honesty. By showing the viewer that the image is built, not found, the art creates a different kind of trust. It does not ask the viewer to believe that they are seeing the past exactly as it was. It asks them to feel what it is like to stand in a space where the past is hidden, or to listen to a story that the world refuses to believe.
This approach is not just about art; it reflects a changing world where digital images can be made to look perfectly real, making it harder to know what is true. In a time when anyone can create a fake photo that looks real, Kwon's choice to make her images look obviously fake becomes a way to tell the truth. The paper suggests that this method of "post-indexical postmemory" helps us deal with the trauma of places we cannot visit and stories we cannot prove. It does not claim to solve the problem of missing history, but it offers a way to carry that history forward without pretending to have evidence that does not exist. The work of Kwon, and the analysis by Han, shows that memory can survive even when the photograph is gone, as long as we are willing to see the construction for what it is.
Drowning in papers in your field?
Get daily digests of the most novel papers matching your research keywords — with technical summaries, in your language.